Meta Ontology

It is widely held that some properties are more natural than others and that, as David Lewis put it, ''an adequate theory of properties is one that recognises an objective difference between natural and unnatural properties'' (Lewis 1983, p. 347). The general line of thought is that such `elitism' about properties is justified as it can give simple and elegant solutions to a number of old metaphysical and philosophical problems. My aim is to analyze what these natural properties are: super-determinates or determinable (or maybe both) and argue that all three of these options would lead to serious difficulties for metaphysical elitism and would prevent natural properties from fulfilling their supposed grand explanatory role.