IRI

http://www.metaontology.pl/metaontology_populated.owl#abstract_3080
Label Language Type
abstract of Against the Modal Argument en rdfs:label

Annotations

  • has text
    • The relationship between alethic modality and indeterminacy is yet to be clarified. A modal argument---an argument that appeals to alethic modality---against vague objects given by Joseph Moore offers a potential clarification of the relationship; it is proposed that there are cases for which the following holds: if it is indeterminate whether A = B then it is possible that it is determinate that A = B. However, the argument faces three problems. The problems remove the argument's threat against vague objects and prompt a fuller scrutiny of Moore's proposed relationship between alethic modality and indeterminacy. Such a scrutiny offers valuable lessons concerning the justification for claims of indeterminate identity, appeals to identity principles in contexts involving both alethic modality and indeterminacy, and how to identify the form of Gareth Evans's argument against vague objects in other arguments

Same Individuals

Object properties

Data properties